Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Cloud Computing and security

Cloud computing has become popular term in recent past. Cloud computing providers have large number of cloud servers interconnected. They provide services to end users - Renting virtual server with CPU power required, Storage and some specialized services such as PHP, Java, Ruby-on-rail based servers etc..

Since these servers are outside of offices, it is required that you have very good internet connectivity. Cheap bandwidth and reliable connectivity favors the cloud computing model. From cloud computing provider perspective, this is becoming possible with very high speed, high density multi core processors and virtualisation with its inherent facility to provide isolation and running multiple services on a physical hardware.

Advantages of cloud computing for users (Enterprises) are same advantages you get with data centers such as
  • Reduce system and network infrastructure administration burden.
  • Save on Electricity cost by selecting data center with lower cost of electricity.
  • Save on real estate.
Cloud computing provides additional advantages such as
  • Handle peak loads by provisioning computing power with a click of a button.
  • Isolation of application servers from physical machines.

There are some concerns which are not yet fully matured.

  • Who is going to take care of security aspects of user applications? Is this cloud computing provider or is it the responsibility of users?
  • Who monitors the vulnerabilities of different applications and takes care of patchoing them?
  • Will there by any visibility provided of exploits and attacks to the user?
  • Who takes responsibility of provisioning security infrastructure? Who takes responsibility of tuning IPS/IDS signatures?
  • Who takes responsibility of complaint requirements such as PCIDSS etc..?
  • Who takes responsibility of auditing systems, application etc..?
  • If you have remote users that need access to these services, what kind of security on the wire required and who provides VPN Connectivity?

When cloud computing provider provides specialized services such as Email etc.., I feel that it is responsibility of cloud computing provider to check for vulnerabilities, hardening, patching, checking for spams and preventing from phishing attacks etc.. Do they do that today? What kind of guarantees provided?

When cloud computing providers provide generic services such as renting out virtual server, I have a feeling that responsibility of security them may fall on user s's shoulders. Now the questions arise such as:

- Do Cloud computing SPs provide *Cloud Security* service?
- Do SPs give flexibility for users to select their own security vendor?
- Do SPs expect security appliance is provisioned as Virtual service? If so, what kind of virtualization technology SPs provide?
- Do SPs provide network visibility for user to link the security service with application servers.


It is not possible for cloud computing providers to provide security for applications which they don't know. Many security problems are specific to each application. Typically Enterprises have their own applications in addition to standard applications. As you see in the questions, there is lot of tuning on security applications, such as adding new signatures in IPS, that happen over time. So, it makes sense for cloud computing providers to provide flexibility for users to create their own security environment. Enterprises also typically provide remote security connectivity for their employees to access critical services. Securing the Enterprise services not only involve exploit detection, tuning, hardening and patching, but also providing VPN service to employees.

I have a feeling that, Like the way computing services are provided in the cloud, security services will also be provided by cloud computing providers. Cloud Security Service provisioning not only involves security application, but also connectivity between security service and application servers. Even to provide complete security, it may involve multiple security services provisioning such as VPN Service, IPS Service, Firewall Service, Web application firewall service or it could be one UTM service.

If Service providers are going to provide flexibility for end users to provision their choice of security application, then SPs would provide choice of running Virtual security appliances.

Yet times, Service provider may not like to provide flexibility of security application and they may provide security as specialized service from them. In those case, SPs may go for mega security appliances supporting multiple instances with instance provisioned for one customer.

Let us see how this market turn out to be.

But, in both cases, need of computation power for security services is very high. Multi core processors are going to fill this gap.

No comments: